Do Colored Pencils Fade and Which Are Most Lightfast
Lightfastness isn't a guarantee of total immortality for your drawings. It’s a measure of how much a color shifts or loses intensity over time when exposed to ultraviolet radiation. Because manufacturers use different binders and pigment concentrations, some pencils lose their vibrancy in weeks, while top-tier options endure for decades. Knowing which brands prioritize stability is the difference between a drawing that lasts a lifetime and one that disappears.
What chemical properties determine the lightfastness of a colored pencil pigment?
The lightfastness of a pigment is primarily dictated by its molecular structure and its ability to resist photo-oxidation when exposed to high-energy electromagnetic radiation.
- Inorganic pigments typically utilize metal oxides or sulfides that possess stable crystalline structures, making them inherently more resistant to light-induced decomposition than their organic counterparts.
- Organic pigments rely on complex synthetic carbon-based molecules that, while vibrant, often feature weaker chemical bonds prone to cleavage under sustained photon bombardment.
- Molecular stability determines how effectively a pigment can dissipate absorbed energy as heat rather than using that energy to break internal bonds and alter the pigment's color.
At a glance
| Brand | Lightfast Rating System | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Caran d'Ache Luminance | ASTM D6901 | Archival work |
| Faber-Castell Polychromos | Blue Wool Scale | Fine detail |
| Prismacolor Premier | Manufacturer specific | Sketching |
How does the Blue Wool Scale measure the resistance of art materials to ultraviolet light?
The Blue Wool Scale functions as a comparative testing standard where eight dyed wool strips, labeled 1 to 8, are exposed to light alongside the test material. The scale is logarithmic, meaning each step represents a doubling of the lightfastness; a material rated 6 is twice as resistant as one rated 5. The testing concludes when the lowest-rated wool strip shows a noticeable change in color.
For instance, a pigment with a rating of 7 is considered highly permanent, showing almost no fading even after prolonged exposure. However, this scale is not absolute. One nuance is that the test measures fading under standardized xenon arc light, which mimics daylight but cannot perfectly replicate the specific spectral shifts found in a home environment where window glass filters out certain wavelengths while allowing others to pass through.
Why do professional-grade pencils typically offer higher lightfast ratings than student-grade alternatives?
Professional-grade pencils achieve superior longevity by prioritizing high-purity pigments over the fillers and dyes commonly used to reduce production costs in student-grade lines.
- Concentration levels in professional pencils are significantly higher, which allows for a denser application of pigment particles that physically shield one another from light exposure.
- Binding agents used in professional sets are selected for their chemical neutrality, preventing the yellowing or brittle textures that often cause premature pigment degradation.
- Grinding processes involve milling pigments to a uniform, fine particle size, which ensures consistent coverage and prevents the uneven fading often seen in cheaper, coarser mixtures.
What environmental factors, such as humidity and framing materials, accelerate the fading process of colored pencil drawings?
High humidity accelerates fading by facilitating chemical reactions between moisture and the binder, while non-archival framing materials like cardboard backings release acidic gases that chemically attack the pigment over time. Using UV-filtering glass is standard practice, but it doesn't stop all damage. A lot of people assume that placing a drawing behind glass creates a perfect seal, but the lack of airflow can actually trap humidity against the paper, leading to mold growth or blooming that obscures the artwork even if the pigments remain chemically intact.
Are there specific binders or waxes that contribute to increased pigment stability over time?
Yes, high-quality synthetic waxes and vegetable-based oils provide superior stability compared to cheaper paraffin binders. Professional pencils often use a blend of these binders that accounts for 20-30% of the core's volume, ensuring the pigment remains suspended in a non-reactive, protective matrix that resists oxidation for decades.
How should artists interpret the lightfastness charts provided by major manufacturers like Faber-Castell, Caran d'Ache, and Prismacolor?
Artists must recognize that manufacturer charts often reflect internal, non-standardized testing rather than the rigorous ASTM D6901 protocol. While a company might label a color as "permanent" based on their own criteria, this may not align with the strict 100-year gallery display requirement. Always look for the specific ASTM rating if available, as it provides a verifiable benchmark for how the pencil will perform under museum-grade conditions.
One concrete example is the difference between a manufacturer's "star" rating and the Blue Wool Scale; a three-star rating from one brand may not equal the same lightfastness as a three-star rating from another. An important nuance is that these charts typically test a single, thick layer of pigment. If you apply the pencil lightly or blend it with a solvent, you are essentially thinning the pigment layer, which significantly reduces its overall resistance to light.
What archival techniques can be employed to protect finished colored pencil works from light-induced degradation?
Framing your work with UV-protective museum glass, which blocks at least 97% of harmful ultraviolet rays, is the most effective way to prevent fading. Keeping the artwork in a climate-controlled environment with humidity levels between 40% and 50% will maintain the structural integrity of the paper.
Common mistakes
- Assuming all colors in a set are equal. Manufacturers often include fugitive, non-lightfast colors in the same box as permanent ones; check the individual barrel ratings.
- Ignoring the paper quality. Even the best lightfast pigments will degrade if the paper contains high acid levels that yellow and brittle over time.
- Overestimating sunlight resistance. Placing a drawing in direct sunlight will degrade even the most archival pigments significantly faster than the manufacturer’s accelerated testing suggests.
Do certain color families, such as transparent yellows or organic reds, exhibit lower lightfastness compared to earth tones?
Organic pigments, particularly transparent yellows and certain reds, are chemically more susceptible to light-induced fading than inorganic earth tones like iron oxides.
| Color Family | Typical Lightfastness |
|---|---|
| Earth Tones | Excellent (ASTM I) |
| Organic Reds | Fair to Good (ASTM II-III) |
| Transparent Yellows | Poor to Fair (ASTM III-IV) |
| Synthetic Blues | Excellent (ASTM I) |
Use these categories to identify which colors in your palette require extra protection or should be avoided for work intended for long-term display.
Selecting pencils for long-term display
Choose professional-grade sets that explicitly list lightfastness ratings for every individual color. Prioritize pencils labeled with ASTM I or II ratings to make sure your work maintains its intended appearance for years to come.