Prismacolor vs Faber-Castell for Blending Colored Pencils

Updated · 6 min read

Choosing between these brands depends on how much physical pressure you apply to the paper. Prismacolor Premier pencils feature a buttery, high-pigment core that moves easily across the page, making them ideal for thick, opaque gradients. Conversely, Faber-Castell Polychromos pencils maintain a harder, more durable point that resists breakage. This allows for intricate, fine-detail blending that would likely cause a softer pencil to crumble or lose its edge under heavy use.

Quick facts

FeaturePrismacolor PremierFaber-Castell Polychromos
BinderWaxOil
Lead TextureSoft/CreamyFirm/Hard
Best ForRapid coverageFine detail
Breakage RiskHigherLower

What are the primary chemical differences between wax-based and oil-based colored pencil binders?

Wax-based pencils rely on paraffin or beeswax to bind pigments, creating a soft, buttery application. Oil-based pencils use vegetable-based oils, which provide a firmer, more stable core. These binders dictate the melting point, with wax-based cores often softening significantly at temperatures above 30 degrees Celsius.

How does the pigment concentration in professional-grade pencils affect the layering process?

High pigment concentration allows for intense color saturation without requiring heavy pressure. In professional-grade lines, the ratio of pigment to binder is optimized to make sure that each stroke deposits a significant amount of color. For instance, a single layer of a high-end pencil often covers more surface area with deeper hue than three layers of a student-grade alternative. This efficiency makes it easier to build complex, luminous transitions without clogging the paper’s tooth prematurely.

However, high pigment density can sometimes create a slick surface if handled incorrectly. If you apply too much pigment too quickly, the particles may sit loosely on the surface rather than anchoring into the paper fibers. This leads to smudging or "burnishing" issues where the paper becomes too smooth to accept further layers. Professionals manage this by alternating between high-pigment strokes and light, structural layers to maintain the necessary surface friction for subsequent work.

Which techniques are most effective for achieving smooth gradients with soft-core versus hard-core pencils?

Soft-core pencils achieve gradients through physical blending of the wax, while hard-core pencils rely on precise, overlapping cross-hatching to create optical color mixtures.

TechniqueSoft-Core (Wax)Hard-Core (Oil)
PressureLow to MediumMedium to High
Stroke StyleCircularCross-hatching
Solvent UseHighly effectiveMinimal impact
Layer Limit3-5 layers6-10 layers

Use these layer limits to gauge when your paper's tooth is full and further blending will only result in mud.

How do different paper textures influence the performance of various colored pencil brands?

Paper with a high tooth, such as 140-pound cold-press watercolor paper, captures more pigment, allowing for deeper, more textured layering. Conversely, smooth surfaces like Bristol board limit the number of layers you can apply because the paper reaches its capacity for pigment adhesion after only 2 or 3 passes.

What role do colorless blenders and solvents play in professional colored pencil artwork?

Colorless blenders are essentially wax or oil binders without pigment, acting as a lubricant to move existing color across the page. Solvents, such as odorless mineral spirits, dissolve the binder entirely, turning the pencil marks into a paint-like consistency. This allows for seamless, brush-like gradients that are impossible to achieve through dry blending alone. For example, using a small brush dipped in solvent can smooth out a rough, multi-layered background in seconds.

One nuance is that solvents can permanently alter the paper's surface structure. Once the binder is dissolved and dried, the paper often loses its original tooth, making it difficult to add fine, sharp details on top of the blended area. Artists must plan their workflow to ensure all fine, dry-pencil work is completed before applying liquid solvents to the piece.

How does the durability of a pencil lead impact the ability to maintain a sharp point for detailed work?

Durability directly dictates how long a lead retains a fine point, which is essential for rendering intricate textures like hair or fine lines.

  • Hard-core leads maintain a needle-sharp point for 10 to 15 minutes of continuous drawing, reducing the need for constant sharpening.
  • Soft-core leads often dull within 2 to 3 minutes of pressure, requiring frequent trips to the sharpener which shortens the pencil's lifespan.
  • Mechanical stress causes softer leads to snap under the pressure of sharp-point detailing, whereas oil-based cores withstand higher force.
  • Sharpening frequency is a primary factor in material waste, as softer brands require more wood removal to achieve a functional point.

What are the common signs of wax bloom, and how can it be prevented or removed during the layering process?

Wax bloom appears as a cloudy, white film on the surface of finished drawings, caused by the wax binder migrating to the top as it cures. It is easily removed by buffing the surface with a clean, soft cloth. A lot of people assume wax bloom is a sign that the pencil quality is poor, but it is actually a natural chemical reaction common in high-wax content pencils. It does not damage the artwork and can be prevented by applying a final fixative spray once the drawing is complete.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Applying too much pressure early. Beginners often press hard to saturate the paper, which fills the tooth and prevents further blending. Use light layers instead.
  • Ignoring the binder type. Mixing oil-based and wax-based pencils without a plan can cause uneven adhesion. Stick to one type per layer for predictable results.
  • Skipping the sharpening. Using a dull pencil for blending creates muddy, imprecise marks. Keep a sharp point to maintain control over the color transition.

How do lightfastness ratings differ between major professional colored pencil manufacturers?

Lightfastness ratings are determined by standardized tests, such as the Blue Wool Scale, which measures how much a pigment fades when exposed to UV light.

  • ASTM D6901 is the industry standard for lightfastness, categorizing colors from I (excellent) to V (poor) based on long-term exposure.
  • Pigment stability varies by color, with earth tones generally remaining stable for 100 years while certain bright pinks or purples may fade within 20.
  • Manufacturer testing involves placing samples in a Xenon arc weatherometer to simulate years of sunlight in a matter of weeks.
  • Professional collections often prioritize pigments that achieve an ASTM I or II rating to make sure the longevity of the finished artwork.

Selecting your ideal blending tool

Select Prismacolor if you prioritize speed and soft, painterly transitions. Opt for Faber-Castell if your work requires sharp edges, high detail, and a cleaner surface that resists the buildup of wax.

Last posts

  1. Are Washable Markers Better for Kids Than Regular Ones
  2. Buying Paint for Large Canvases Sizing and Scale Tips
  3. Are Tombow Pens Good for Blending Colors
  4. Are Posca Pens Worth the Money for Art Projects
  5. Is Mont Marte Good for Budget Art Supplies
  6. Are Americolor Gel Colors Worth the Money for Baking
  7. Are Wilton Gel Colors Better Than Liquid for Frosting
  8. Is Mod Podge a Good Sealer for Painted Crafts?
  9. Is Rit Dye Good Enough for Home Projects and Clothing
  10. Is Procion Better Than Rit for Tie-Dye Professional Results