Best Paint Sets for Trying Every Medium

Updated · 5 min read

Many beginners assume a large, tiered box set is the most efficient way to sample different paints. However, these kits frequently include low-pigment student-grade paints that make color mixing frustrating and muddy. Professional-grade paints offer higher pigment loads, meaning a small 15ml tube lasts significantly longer than a larger tube of budget paint. Focusing on quality over quantity prevents the discouragement that comes from using materials that don't behave as intended.

Key numbers

MediumDrying TimePigment Load
WatercolorMinutesHigh
Acrylic10-30 minsHigh
Oil2-7 daysHighest

What are the fundamental differences between oil, acrylic, and watercolor paints in terms of drying time and technique?

Watercolor relies on water as the vehicle, drying quickly by evaporation, which demands rapid, decisive brushwork. You build luminosity through transparent layers, starting from the lightest values. In contrast, oils use drying oils like linseed, which oxidize over days or weeks. This slow process allows for extensive blending and the "fat over lean" technique, where you apply thicker, oil-rich layers over thinner ones to prevent cracking. Acrylics bridge this gap, drying through polymer coalescence into a flexible, water-resistant plastic film.

While acrylics are generally permanent once dry, they can be reactivated with specialized mediums or kept workable longer using retarders. A common example is the "wet-on-wet" technique, which is effortless in oil but requires significant practice in watercolor due to the paper’s absorbency. One nuance is that watercolor can be lifted from the paper with a damp brush even after drying, unlike the other two.

Which essential supplies are required for a beginner to start painting with multiple mediums?

You'll need a modest collection of versatile tools to handle the distinct requirements of these three traditional painting mediums.

  • Synthetic brushes: These are superior for acrylics and watercolors because they resist the degradation caused by alkaline acrylic resins and don't lose their shape in water.
  • Palette knives: Metal versions are essential for mixing oils without contaminating your brushes and for applying thick, impasto textures that bristles cannot achieve.
  • Glass palettes: A tempered glass surface provides a non-porous area that is easy to scrape clean, regardless of whether you are using sticky oils or fast-drying acrylics.
  • Mason jars: Keep at least three separate containers for water and solvent to avoid muddying your colors during a session.

How do different types of painting surfaces, such as canvas, paper, and wood panels, affect the performance of various paints?

The surface, or substrate, dictates how paint sits and adheres. Canvas provides a flexible, toothy surface ideal for oils, while heavy-weight cold-press paper is designed to absorb watercolor pigments without buckling. Wood panels offer a rigid, smooth foundation that resists the warping common with canvas. Many people assume that any primer works for every medium, but you must use a gesso specifically formulated for acrylics if you intend to use acrylic paint, as oil-based primers can prevent acrylics from bonding properly, eventually causing the paint film to peel away entirely.

What safety precautions should be taken when handling solvents, mediums, and pigments across different paint types?

Proper ventilation and chemical management are required to protect your respiratory health while working with various pigments and solvents.

  • Turpentine: This traditional solvent is highly volatile and requires a dedicated exhaust fan or an open window to prevent the buildup of harmful vapors in your workspace.
  • Cadmium pigments: These heavy metal-based paints are toxic if inhaled as dust, so always purchase them in pre-mixed tube form rather than dry powder to avoid airborne particles.
  • Nitrile gloves: Wear these when handling oil paints or solvents to prevent skin absorption, as some pigments can irritate or penetrate the dermis over long sessions.
  • Waste disposal: Store solvent-soaked rags in a sealed, water-filled metal container to prevent the risk of spontaneous combustion.

How does the cost of professional-grade versus student-grade paint affect the learning experience for a beginner?

Professional paints offer higher pigment density, meaning you use less product to achieve the same color intensity compared to student-grade alternatives.

Paint TypeAverage Cost per mlPigment Concentration
Student Grade$0.20 - $0.4020-30%
Professional Grade$0.80 - $1.5050-70%

Because professional tubes have double or triple the pigment load, you can dilute them significantly with mediums or water, often making them more cost-effective in the long run.

Can different painting mediums be mixed together on the same canvas, and what are the risks of doing so?

No, mixing mediums like oil and water-based acrylics on the same canvas is risky because they have different expansion rates. If you apply oil over acrylic, it may adhere, but acrylic applied over oil will eventually peel off due to the oil's 100 percent non-polar surface.

What are the most effective ways to store and maintain brushes and tools when working with diverse paint formulas?

Maintaining your tools requires a specific cleaning protocol tailored to the binder of the paint you just used.

  1. Clean synthetic brushes used for acrylics immediately with cool water and mild soap, as dried acrylic acts like permanent plastic.
  2. Wipe excess oil paint off brushes with a paper towel before dipping them into a non-toxic brush cleaner or safflower oil.
  3. Reshape the bristles of your brushes after washing to make sure they dry in their original form.
  4. Store brushes horizontally or with bristles pointing upward in a jar to prevent the tips from bending or fraying under their own weight.
  5. Inspect ferrules for dried residue, as buildup here forces bristles apart and ruins the brush's ability to hold a sharp edge.

What people often get wrong

  • Buying student-grade sets. These contain excessive binders and fillers, making it impossible to learn how pigments truly interact. Buy fewer tubes of professional quality instead.
  • Ignoring lightfastness ratings. Some cheap pigments fade within months of hanging on a wall. Check the tube for an ASTM rating of I or II to ensure longevity.
  • Over-purchasing colors. Beginners often buy 24-color sets they never fully use. A limited palette of six colors teaches color theory far more effectively.

Building a flexible painting kit

Invest in a small, high-quality selection of professional paints to understand how different mediums respond to your brush. Prioritize learning color mixing with a limited palette before expanding your collection with specialized colors or extra tools.

Last posts

  1. Best Watercolors for Realistic Water and Marine Scenes
  2. Best Paint for Animal Portraits and Realistic Fur Textures
  3. Best Paint Sets for Mixing Sunset Colors by Medium
  4. Best Paints for Abstract Color Mixing and Blending
  5. Best Paints for Beginner Seascapes and How to Choose
  6. Best Paint Sets for Floral Art and Mixing Natural Hues
  7. Best White Paint for Mixing Pastels and Soft Hues
  8. Mixing Neutral Gray Backgrounds for Professional Painting
  9. Best Black and White Paint Sets for Value Studies
  10. Mixing Realistic Leaf Greens with Professional Paint Pigments